top of page

Toasted Marshmallow Milkshake!

I would describe myself more savory than sweet when it comes to food. None times out of ten, I will pick chips over chocolate. But when I do have a sweet tooth, I look for pure decadence. I have mentioned The Hamilton in DC because they are simply the best for sushi happy hour and bringing bold flavors together in their food. When I have ordered dessert there, it usually is one of their cakes or beignets. However, the Toasted Marshmallow milkshake caught my eye. I asked the waitress her opinion and she said it was popular, but seemed super sweet to her. I tried it and it was the best thing I’ve ever tasted. It is presented in a tall glass and jumbo straw. Even though I love ordering it from The Hamilton, I knew I could recreate the flavor at home for less than $8.00 a glass.

I know I say it all the time, but Pinterest has everything. No matter how crazy the recipe, I can always find something similar on there. I went searching for a dupe recipe and found several. I picked up marshmallows from Whole Foods and got the rest of the ingredients from the local grocery store. There were a few ways to toast the marshmallows for the signature taste. Instead of standing over an open flame, I toasted them in the oven on broil with the door open. The instructions were to cut them in half so you could achieve a deeper toasty flavor instead of leaving them whole. I placed them on parchment paper and watched in amazement. After they toasted, I put them in a blender cup with the ice cream, milk and a little vanilla extract. I prefer a thicker milkshake, so I added more ice cream. The flavor was almost identical to The Hamilton. I toasted a whole marshmallow for presentation and served it in a mason jar glass.

The flavor of the milkshake was so rich and decadent. It was almost similar to a s’more without the chocolate and graham crackers. I will definitely be making this milkshake again. Also if you are feeling like an extra kick, you can also make it boozy for your enjoyment!

Featured Posts
Recent Posts
Search By Tags
Follow Us
  • Facebook Basic Square
  • Twitter Basic Square
  • Google+ Basic Square
bottom of page